Head-to-Head Comparison

Blue Guardian vs TradeDay

An honest, data-driven comparison to help you pick the right prop firm. We compare drawdown rules, challenge costs, profit splits, trading conditions, and more — no bias, just facts.

Blue Guardian

4.6

Innovative prop firm featuring the Guardian Shield risk management system. Offers 24-hour payout guarantee and scaling up to $4M with multiple funding models.

Visit Blue Guardian

TradeDay

4.1

Futures prop firm offering competitive pricing with up to $750K in allocations and trader-friendly rules.

Visit TradeDay

Side-by-Side Comparison: Blue Guardian vs TradeDay

Metric

Blue Guardian

TradeDay

Max Drawdown

Daily Drawdown

Profit Target

10%

Profit Split

85/15 → 90/10

80/20 → 90/10

Challenge Cost

$87 - $897

$99 - $499

Trading Period

Unlimited

Min Trading Days

Leverage

1:100

Exchange margin

Instruments

Forex, Crypto, Indices, Commodities

Futures

Account Sizes

$10K, $25K, $50K, $100K, $200K

$25K, $50K, $100K, $150K, $250K

Scaling

25% account increase every 3 months at 12% profit, up to $4M

Max allocations $750K

News Trading

Not Allowed

Allowed

Weekend Holding

Allowed

Not Allowed

EA / Bots

Allowed

Rating

4.6/5

4.1/5

The Verdict: Blue Guardian vs TradeDay

The best choice depends on your trading style, risk tolerance, and goals. Here's our breakdown by trader profile:

Best for Beginners

TradeDay

TradeDay offers more forgiving drawdown rules, making it easier for newer traders to get started.

Best for Aggressive Traders

TradeDay

TradeDay provides 8% max drawdown allowance, giving aggressive trading styles more breathing room.

Best for Long-term Scaling

Blue Guardian

Blue Guardian offers better scaling potential: 25% account increase every 3 months at 12% profit, up to $4M.

Best for Overall Value

Blue Guardian

Blue Guardian earns 4.6/5 in our analysis, with a strong balance of rules, cost, and trader experience.

Blue Guardian Pros & Cons

24-hour payout guarantee or 100% profit split

Guardian Shield risk management system

Scaling up to $4M

85% base profit split (higher than most)

Overnight and weekend holding allowed

No news trading on funded accounts

Guardian Shield can close trades at 1-2% loss

Second Shield breach terminates account

US traders restricted from some features

Fee refund only after 4th payout

TradeDay Pros & Cons

Generous allocation limits

Competitive pricing

Up to 90% profit split

Clear evaluation rules

No time pressure

Futures only

Limited instrument variety

Newer brand

Cannot hold over weekends

Mid-range recognition

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

It depends on your trading style. Blue Guardian offers 6% max drawdown and a 85/15 → 90/10 profit split, while TradeDay offers 8% max drawdown and a 80/20 → 90/10 split. Blue Guardian has a higher overall rating at 4.6/5.

What is the cheapest option between Blue Guardian and TradeDay?

Blue Guardian challenges start at $87 - $897, while TradeDay starts at $99 - $499. Compare account sizes and what's included before choosing based on price alone.

Can I use EAs or trading bots with Blue Guardian and TradeDay?

Blue Guardian allows EAs/bots. TradeDay allows them. Always verify the latest rules on each firm's website.

What are the drawdown rules for Blue Guardian vs TradeDay?

Blue Guardian has a 6% max drawdown and 4% daily drawdown. TradeDay has a 8% max drawdown and 4% daily drawdown. Use our free Drawdown Calculator to find your safe lot size for either firm.

How long do I have to pass the Blue Guardian vs TradeDay challenge?

Blue Guardian gives you Unlimited. TradeDay gives you Unlimited. Both require a minimum of 5 and 5 trading days respectively.

Which firm has a better profit split, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian offers a 85/15 → 90/10 profit split, while TradeDay offers 80/20 → 90/10. Higher profit splits mean more of your trading profits go to you.